I really enjoyed these alternative book reviews. I have struggled with the best way to write a review, and it's fascinating to see these vastly different takes on the same story juxtaposed--especially when I know they've come from the same reviewer!
Great reviews, Terry - I very much prefer the second, specifically for its empathy and humanity, and I’m interested in finding out more about this intriguing character. The first is a rather more direct ‘he said this, then he said that’ kind of style, and doesn’t make me want to know any more! I’d leave that one on the shelf. 😉
Hehehehehe. Well that gave me a morning chuckle. Those reviews are awesome. I love this.
Re: the solution. Wow. Don't think I would have gotten that. I was trying to think way outside of that box. Such a good technique to apply though. Must have taken a while?
Also, I was in the wonderfully large Dymocks in Melbourne's CBD yesterday and spotted The Penguin Book of Oulipo! I shall pick it up at some point, but I was after a book by Kobe Abe to read (the Oulipo book was right next to it!)
Thanks, Nathan. Glad you liked the reviews. I enjoyed writing them, especially the negative one. (Though not on the same league as a review I read which began: "This the worst book on educational I've ever read" and ended "The trees died screaming for this one"
Yes, took me ages. Every time I thought of a word, I realised it broke the rule. Hence the awful convoluted phrases.
May 14, 2023·edited May 14, 2023Liked by Terry Freedman
"Well, it forced me to tie myself in verbal knots..."
Forced YOU?! What about us poor readers? I mean, I've been tied up in those verbal knots of yours for A WEEK, Terry. 👀😉
Oh, and bravo, by the way - this was an absolutely epic challenge! 🙌🥳😁
Now, if you'll excuse me I'm off to read the rest of your post, because obviously so far I've ignored everything in it apart from the solution to last week's.
Very cool constraint - sounds really fun and now I want to try it too!
Thanks, Jill. You should!
I really enjoyed these alternative book reviews. I have struggled with the best way to write a review, and it's fascinating to see these vastly different takes on the same story juxtaposed--especially when I know they've come from the same reviewer!
😂
Have you ever played zendo? It's a brillant game about deducing constraints.
https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/6830/zendo
Thanks Justus I'm checking that out right now!
Great reviews, Terry - I very much prefer the second, specifically for its empathy and humanity, and I’m interested in finding out more about this intriguing character. The first is a rather more direct ‘he said this, then he said that’ kind of style, and doesn’t make me want to know any more! I’d leave that one on the shelf. 😉
I take your point, Rebecca. Isn't interesting, though, how they both convey exactly the same information but with such a different feel?
Yes! Same data, different serving style. Fascinating stuff!
Hehehehehe. Well that gave me a morning chuckle. Those reviews are awesome. I love this.
Re: the solution. Wow. Don't think I would have gotten that. I was trying to think way outside of that box. Such a good technique to apply though. Must have taken a while?
Also, I was in the wonderfully large Dymocks in Melbourne's CBD yesterday and spotted The Penguin Book of Oulipo! I shall pick it up at some point, but I was after a book by Kobe Abe to read (the Oulipo book was right next to it!)
Thanks, Nathan. Glad you liked the reviews. I enjoyed writing them, especially the negative one. (Though not on the same league as a review I read which began: "This the worst book on educational I've ever read" and ended "The trees died screaming for this one"
Yes, took me ages. Every time I thought of a word, I realised it broke the rule. Hence the awful convoluted phrases.
Buy the Oulipo book today!!!😱😱
I really should have just picked it up anyway. But I'll be back in there soon. I imagine I'll be tearing through The Woman in the Dunes.
Thoroughly enjoyed review 2 👏🏻 And wowsers to the solution to last week’s textual mystery!
Thanks, Claire. Just put of interest, what did you like about #2?
That upbeat and positive tone, I guess. And nice and wordy ... just how I like a review!!
Thanks, Claire :-)
"Well, it forced me to tie myself in verbal knots..."
Forced YOU?! What about us poor readers? I mean, I've been tied up in those verbal knots of yours for A WEEK, Terry. 👀😉
Oh, and bravo, by the way - this was an absolutely epic challenge! 🙌🥳😁
Now, if you'll excuse me I'm off to read the rest of your post, because obviously so far I've ignored everything in it apart from the solution to last week's.
Sorry!😩😂
😉 and 🙌. AWESOME!